In a season already marred by injuries, the New York Yankees are facing a critical decision regarding their pitching rotation as they look to acquire a replacement for the sidelined Gerrit Cole. With Cole out for the season and fellow pitcher Luis Gil recently diagnosed with a serious lat strain, the Yankees find themselves in a precarious position. The team’s depth has been significantly tested, prompting discussions about potential trades to bolster their starting lineup.
The Yankees had high hopes for a dominant rotation in 2025, anchored by Cole and Carlos Rodón, but injuries have cast doubts on their plans. Reports indicate that the Yankees are exploring options in the trade market, with names like Jordan Montgomery, a former Yankee, being highlighted as a potential target. Montgomery, who helped the Texas Rangers clinch a World Series title in 2023, had a rocky 2024 season with the Arizona Diamondbacks. His struggles have left Arizona eager to part ways, presenting an opportunity for the Yankees to snag him at a lower price.
While Montgomery’s past success in New York could ease his transition back, concerns remain about his recent performance. The Yankees would need to weigh the risks against the potential benefits, especially given the current uncertainty surrounding their pitching staff. If a deal can be struck that allows Arizona to absorb some of Montgomery’s salary, it may be worth pursuing. The Yankees could also consider trading Marcus Stroman, whose relationship with the front office appears strained.
Brian Cashman faces a pivotal moment. With injuries likely to continue throughout the season, the Yankees cannot afford to enter 2025 with a shaky rotation. The time for action is now, and acquiring Montgomery could be the strategic move needed to keep the Yankees competitive. As fans await developments, the question remains: is bringing Montgomery back to the Bronx the right call for the Yankees? The answer may define their season ahead.