In a whirlwind of emotions, New York Yankees fans are grappling with the news of ace pitcher Garrett Cole being sidelined for the entire season due to Tommy John surgery. However, a glimmer of hope has emerged as Cole underwent the procedure using an innovative internal bracing technique that could expedite his recovery, potentially allowing him to return by Opening Day 2026. This news has sparked renewed discussions about the state of the Yankees’ roster and the potential for a blockbuster trade, particularly for star third baseman Nolan Arenado.
Cole, the reigning AL Cy Young winner, has been a cornerstone of the Yankees’ pitching rotation. Despite battling elbow issues last season, he maintained an impressive 8-5 record in 17 starts, showcasing his competitive spirit. With Opening Day set for March 27 against the Brewers, the Yankees now face the daunting task of reshaping their rotation in the absence of their ace.
As injuries mount, including John Carlos Stanton’s indefinite absence and DJ LeMahieu sidelined for weeks, the urgency for the Yankees to make a significant move has intensified. Arenado, a ten-time Gold Glove winner and elite defender, has been a long-discussed trade target. While his offensive performance dipped last season, the Yankees’ front office may feel the pressure to act as rival teams strengthen their rosters.
Despite previous hesitance due to Arenado’s contract and salary, the current circumstances may compel the Yankees to reconsider. The Cardinals have reportedly rejected an initial offer from New York, and Arenado’s no-trade clause complicates negotiations, but he has shown willingness to be traded to the Yankees in the past.
If a trade doesn’t materialize, the Yankees have internal options, such as Oswaldo Cabrera and promising prospect Spencer Jones. However, to keep pace with powerful teams like the Orioles, Rangers, and Astros, a more aggressive approach may be necessary. As the season approaches, the Yankees find themselves at a crossroads, needing to balance urgency with strategic decision-making. Fans are left to wonder: will the Yankees pull the trigger on a trade for Arenado, or will they rely on homegrown talent as they navigate a challenging season?